Remember that song by Edie Brickell? "Choke me in the shallow waters before I get too deep." I can't help but look around and wonder if people are saying that or if they just don't even realize they are in the shallow water. Maybe it is just an issue of comfort and safety. At the risk of sounding elitist (something I commented to Terri earlier tonight I didn't want to do), I look around and see so much shallowness in our southern (particularly) evangelical subculture. It really makes me sick. I want desperately to deepen my relationships with others and thus my community, but it is a never-ending stream of shallow water.
Example: I am probably stepping into it a bit here based on who reads this blog, but here it is. Our church is offering a Ladies' Summer Book Club which will read the book Captivating: Unveiling the Mystery of a Woman's Soul. Why do I, as a male, care about this? Because I think it perpetuates shallow stereotypes. No, I haven't read the book, so please don't avoid it simply because of what you read here. I have discussed Eldredge's other books (Wild at Heart) with folks, and I came away nonplussed. A couple of reviews from Amazon:
John Eldredge became the Robert Bly of evangelicalism with his blockbuster Wild at Heart.
Now he teams up with his wife, Stasi, to encourage women to connect
with their deepest desires. To facilitate this, the Eldredges reveal in
the first chapter what every woman's three core desires are: to be
romanced, to play a role in her own adventures and to display beauty.
Every little girl has dreams of being swept up into a great
adventure, of being the beautiful princess. Sadly, when women grow up,
they are often swept up into a life filled merely with duty and
demands. Many Christian women are tired, struggling under the weight of
the pressure to be a "good servant," a nurturing caregiver, or a
capable home manager.
What Wild at Heart did for men, Captivating
can do for women. This groundbreaking book shows readers the glorious
design of women before the fall, describes how the feminine heart can
be restored, and casts a vision for the power, freedom, and beauty of a
woman released to be all she was meant to be.
Who says those are every woman's deepest desires? Not being a woman myself, I went to my source (my wife) and asked her. She reported she in fact had other deep desires like seeing God glorified, seeing our son become a godly man, seeing justice done in the world, hearing the Scripture rightly divided, etc. She further told me that not once growing up did she ever dream of being the beautiful princess. Now surely some women do have these desires and some girls do dream of being the beautiful princess, but that's not the claim. The claim is all, and that is a shallow stereotype. I fail to see how the book is groundbreaking in any sense of the word. Bottom line, what are we studying in the church? It just seems like pop theology to me. It is no small wonder why I often wonder whether I am sitting in church or on the set of Oprah.
Where is the depth? This lined up well with two blog posts I read today. The first from Andrew Jones (Tall Skinny Kiwi) sharing Barna's research that despite churches in America spending close to a trillion dollars in the past two decades on domestic ministry there has been no noticeable impact on people coming to Christ. The second from Joel Vestal sharing a survey from April of this year related to the top ten issues to Southern Baptists. Joel decried that global outreach, justice, and mission did not make the list. I guess we're just too busy being wild at heart.
Terri summed it up well for me in saying, "While it may say some good things, it also
subtly reinforces and perpetuates false assumptions and stereotypes about women
(as did the author’s book about men) that in my opinion do more harm than
good (and seem to be based more on psychology than biblical principles)."
Okay, that's the end of the rant. Again, I haven't read the book. I'm trying to speak to an issue larger than just one book. As far as the book goes, I found a blog post from Michael Spencer (the internet monk) from last summer that shares some of these same thoughts but is also much more generous. I point you there for further reflection.
Recent Comments